KRISTOFFER MONICO S. NG
Attorney-at-Law

Tag: Retirement

  • Can an Employer Retire an Employee Before Age 65?

    Can an Employer Retire an Employee Before Age 65?

    Retirement is often treated as a routine stage of employment. An employee reaches a certain age, the employer processes the retirement benefits, and the employment relationship comes to an end. Under Philippine labor law, however, reaching retirement age does not always mean that an employer can require an employee to leave.

    In Rodolfo C. Ondevilla v. Colegio de San Juan de Letran (Laguna), Inc., G.R. No. 278615, promulgated on June 29, 2026, the Supreme Court addressed whether an employee could be treated as having voluntarily retired before reaching the compulsory retirement age. The decision offers a useful reminder to employers: if retirement is optional, the employee must actually choose to retire. An employer cannot simply characterize the end of employment as retirement and assume that the matter is settled.

    Is 65 the mandatory retirement age?

    Article 302, formerly Article 287, of the Labor Code, as amended, recognizes two (2) forms of retirement for employees in the private sector: optional retirement at age 60 and compulsory retirement at age 65. The law generally allows an employee who has reached 60 to retire, provided the applicable statutory conditions are met. At 65, compulsory retirement ordinarily applies.

    The word “optional” here deserves closer attention. Under the law, who holds the option to retire at age 60 – the employer or the employee? The answer determines whether reaching that age allows an employer to end the employment relationship or merely gives the employee the choice to retire. Optional retirement vests the choice in the employee.

    In Ondevilla, the Supreme Court reiterated that an employee who has not expressly agreed to early retirement cannot be retired before reaching age 65. The Court emphasized that acceptance of an early retirement option must be explicit, voluntary, free, and uncompelled. Thus, an employer cannot simply require an employee to retire upon reaching age 60 and treat the employee’s silence or circumstances as consent to retirement.

    What the Supreme Court said in Ondevilla?

    The case involved Rodolfo C. Ondevilla, who had worked for Colegio de San Juan de Letran in Laguna since 2004. He eventually became the school’s assistant vice president for finance. Following a management reorganization in 2018, he was reassigned to a lower position, which he challenged as a demotion.

    The school subsequently treated Ondevilla as having retired at age 60. He disputed that characterization and filed a complaint for illegal dismissal.

    The case reached the Supreme Court after proceedings before the labor arbiter, the National Labor Relations Commission, and the Court of Appeals. The central question concerning retirement was whether Ondevilla had voluntarily elected to retire before reaching age 65.

    The Court ruled that he had not.

    The dispute centered on a letter Ondevilla sent to the school on October 29, 2019, in response to its demand that he settle a ₱2,387,000 cash advance. He explained that the advance had been approved by the previous management because he was a regular employee entitled to retirement benefits. He also challenged his demotion and the school’s treatment of him as a consultant, demanded reinstatement, and questioned the denial of his retirement benefits.

    The Court of Appeals interpreted Ondevilla’s reference to July 31, 2020, as the end of the school year, as an election to retire on that date. The Supreme Court disagreed. Read in context, the letter addressed the school’s demand for payment and did not expressly communicate a decision to retire. The school had not offered or proposed a retirement arrangement for him to accept, while his objections and complaint for illegal dismissal contradicted the claim that he had voluntarily chosen to retire.

    The Court reiterated that acceptance of early retirement must be “explicit, voluntary, free and uncompelled.” An employer cannot infer consent from an ambiguous statement or the employee’s conduct. Finding that Ondevilla had been illegally dismissed, the Court awarded backwages, separation pay in lieu of reinstatement, retirement benefits under Article 302 of the Labor Code, and attorney’s fees, remanding the case to the labor arbiter for computation of the monetary award.

    The case illustrates why an employer should not rely on an employee’s age, an ambiguous statement, or a reference to company practice to establish early retirement. The employer must be able to show that the employee actually and voluntarily chose to retire under the applicable arrangement.

    What if the employer wants an employee to retire before age 65?

    There may be legitimate business reasons for an employer to introduce an earlier retirement arrangement. A company may want to establish a succession plan, reorganize its workforce, or provide a retirement package to long-serving employees. The law does not prevent employers from offering voluntary early retirement arrangements, provided the applicable legal requirements are observed.

    In my view, an employer who wants an employee to retire early has three possible routes.

    1. Check whether an existing retirement arrangement allows it.

    Start with the company’s retirement plan, employment contracts, and collective bargaining agreement, if any. The law allows the parties to agree on a retirement age below 65, including an arrangement that gives the employer the option to implement early retirement. The plan itself, however, must have been validly adopted with the employees’ consent, and the applicable retirement benefits must comply with legal requirements. An employer cannot simply introduce an early retirement policy and impose it on employees who never agreed to it.

    2. If no such arrangement exists, make an offer.

    An employer may propose a voluntary early retirement package, specifying the proposed retirement date, benefits, computation, and other terms. The employee should have a genuine opportunity to consider the offer without threats or undue pressure. If the employee accepts, document the agreement clearly. If the employee declines, the employer cannot treat the offer as an instruction to retire.

    3. If the employee refuses, consider other lawful options.

    If the position is no longer needed: Consider a genuine redundancy program. For example, if the company is consolidating departments, automating functions, or eliminating overlapping positions, it may assess whether the employee’s position has become redundant. The employer must establish the factual basis for redundancy, apply fair and reasonable selection criteria where necessary, provide the required notices, and pay the prescribed separation pay. Redundancy cannot be manufactured simply to remove an employee who refuses to retire.

    If the concern is the employee’s performance: Address it through the company’s performance management process. Set clear expectations, document deficiencies, provide appropriate opportunities to improve, and determine whether the circumstances support any lawful action under the Labor Code. An employee’s age or refusal to retire does not, by itself, establish a valid ground for dismissal.

    If the employer simply wants to part ways, and the employee declines early retirement, the employer can explore other arrangements depending on its operational needs and the employee’s willingness to participate:

    1. Offer a career transition package. Instead of presenting retirement as an ultimatum, offer enhanced benefits in exchange for a genuinely voluntary separation. The package may include additional compensation, extended health benefits where feasible, outplacement services, or assistance in transitioning to another job.

    2. Explore a different role. If the concern is that the employee’s current position no longer fits the organization’s needs, consider reassignment to a suitable vacant position, subject to the employment contract, applicable law, and the employee’s rights. This may preserve the employment relationship while addressing the company’s operational concerns.

    3. Agree on a phased transition. Where the business needs continuity and the employee is willing, the parties may agree on a transition period during which the employee transfers responsibilities, trains a successor, or gradually reduces working hours. Any change in duties, hours, or compensation should be properly agreed upon and documented.

    4. Consider consultancy after separation. If the employee has specialized knowledge that the company still needs, the parties may explore a genuine consultancy arrangement following a voluntary separation. The arrangement must reflect an actual independent-contractor relationship and should not be used to disguise continuing employment.

    5. Plan for succession without ending employment prematurely. If the concern is that a senior employee occupies a position needed by a successor, the company can implement succession planning, delegate responsibilities, or create a transition role while the employee remains employed. This allows the organization to prepare for eventual retirement without prematurely terminating the existing employment relationship.

    6. Consider a negotiated separation arrangement. Depending on the circumstances, this may involve separation pay, additional compensation, and mutually agreed terms for ending employment. The arrangement should accurately reflect what the parties have agreed upon and should be reviewed for compliance with applicable labor laws. A negotiated separation should not simply be described as retirement if the employee has not actually elected to retire.

    Final Word

    Philippine labor law recognizes optional retirement at age 60 and compulsory retirement at age 65 for covered private-sector employees, subject to applicable retirement plans, agreements, and other legally recognized arrangements. An employer may therefore have lawful ways to arrange retirement before age 65, but the legal basis must be established.

    Where early retirement is optional, the employee must genuinely choose it. An employer that wants an employee to leave before age 65 should review the applicable retirement arrangements, consider a voluntary retirement offer, document the employee’s actual decision, or explore another lawful arrangement suited to the circumstances.

    The practical lesson from Ondevilla is straightforward: an employer should establish the legal basis for early retirement before ending the employment relationship. Treating an employee as retired without establishing valid consent can turn what was intended to be a routine personnel decision into an illegal dismissal case.

    Atty. Kristoffer Monico S. Ng is a Philippine lawyer whose practice focuses on labor and employment, corporate and commercial law, tax, energy law, and civil and criminal litigation. He advises businesses and individuals on legal risk, regulatory compliance, taxation, dispute resolution, and complex commercial matters, representing clients before courts, quasi-judicial agencies, and administrative bodies, while also providing strategic legal advice outside the courtroom. He also regularly writes on developments in Philippine jurisprudence and regulation, providing practical insights on legal issues affecting businesses and individuals.

    If you require legal advice concerning employee retirement, early retirement programs, illegal dismissal, separation pay, or other labor and employment matters, you may reach him through e-mail at nico@nlaw.ph to discuss your particular circumstances.

    Suggested Article:

    In a previous article, we discussed when “one-half month salary” means 15 days and when it means 22.5 days. Read our discussion on how retirement pay, retrenchment, redundancy, and voluntary separation programs are computed under Philippine labor law, and why employers should clearly define the legal basis and computation of separation benefits

  • When “One-Half Month Salary” Means 15 Days—and When It Means 22.5 Days

    When “One-Half Month Salary” Means 15 Days—and When It Means 22.5 Days

    A recent labor dispute involving a voluntary separation program brought to the fore an issue that employers do not always anticipate when designing separation packages: how should “one-half month salary” be computed?

    The dispute arose after an employer introduced a one-time voluntary separation program, notably denominated as “Early Retirement Offer”. Under the program, employees who wished to avail of it could apply for voluntary separation and, if their applications were accepted, receive separation pay equivalent to one-half month salary for every year of service.

    There was, however, an important qualification.

    The program was not intended by the employer to be a retirement program in the sense contemplated by the Labor Code. Although the program was denominated as “Early Retirement Offer”, it was voluntary, was offered without regard to age or seniority, and was not part of the employees’ employment contracts or a collective bargaining agreement. Management likewise reserved the right to defer or reject an employee’s request based on business requirements of the employer, and participation in the program did not permanently sever the employee’s opportunity to work for the employer, as employees who availed themselves of the offer were permitted to reapply after two (2) years.

    Despite these conditions, the use of the words “Early Retirement Offer” created an understandable source of confusion – the phrase “one-half month salary.”

    For the company, the phrase meant 50% of the employee’s monthly salary. In practical terms, this meant 15 days’ worth of salary. To this end, the company informed the employees that the 22.5-day formula under the Labor Code would not apply because the program was not intended to constitute statutory retirement. One employee, however, took a different view. After availing of the offer, he filed a case challenging the computation of his separation pay, arguing that “one-half month salary” should instead be computed using the 22.5-day formula applicable to statutory retirement pay.

    The dispute illustrates an important point in Philippine labor law: “one-half month salary” does not necessarily mean the same thing in every context. For statutory retirement pay, the Supreme Court has expressly interpreted one-half month salary to mean 22.5 days. For other forms of separation, however, the applicable computation depends upon the particular law, agreement, or program governing the payment.

    The 22.5-Day Rule for Retirement Pay

    The reason for the 22.5-day computation is found in the Labor Code.

    Article 302, formerly Article 287, of the Labor Code provides that in the absence of a retirement plan or agreement providing for retirement benefits, a qualified employee is entitled to retirement pay equivalent to at least one-half month salary for every year of service. The provision, however, does not stop at the words “one-half month salary.” It expressly defines the term:

    “Unless the parties provide for broader inclusions, the term one-half (1/2) month salary shall mean fifteen (15) days plus one-twelfth (1/12) of the 13th month pay and the cash equivalent of not more than five (5) days of service incentive leaves.”
    The resulting computation, therefore, is 22.5 days, and the Supreme Court has repeatedly recognized this interpretation.

    In Grace Christian High School v. Lavandera (G.R. No. 177845, 20 August 2014), the Court considered the proper computation of retirement benefits under a school retirement plan. The employer had computed the employee’s retirement benefits using one-half month salary but did not include the 13th month pay and service incentive leave components required under the statutory retirement scheme. Relying on Elegir v. Philippine Airlines, Inc., the Court ruled that one-half month salary for purposes of statutory retirement pay means 22.5 days: 15 days, plus 2.5 days representing one-twelfth of the 13th month pay, plus 5 days representing service incentive leave.

    Thus, where the payment involved is statutory retirement pay, the rule is clear: one-half month salary means 22.5 days. This, however, is not because “half a month” is inherently equivalent to 22.5 days. It is rather because the law specifically defines the term that way for purposes of retirement pay.

    The Meaning of “One-Half Month” Depends on the Benefit Involved

    This distinction is easy to overlook. Once an employee or employer becomes familiar with the 22.5-day retirement formula, there is a natural tendency to apply it whenever the words “one-half month” appear in a labor-related benefit. The statutory provisions, however, do not necessarily operate that way. The retirement provision contains a specific definition of “one-half month salary.” Other provisions governing separation pay, on the other hand, do not contain the same definition. The question, therefore, should not simply be how many days constitute one-half month. The more appropriate inquiry is: What is the legal basis of the payment being made?

    If it is statutory retirement pay, the 22.5-day rule applies. If it is separation pay arising from an authorized cause, the applicable provision on separation pay must instead be examined. If it is a voluntary separation program created by the employer, the terms of that program must be examined to determine what benefit the employer actually agreed to provide.

    Retrenchment Uses a Different Formula

    Under Article 298 of the Labor Code, an employee terminated because of retrenchment to prevent losses is entitled to separation pay equivalent to one month pay or at least one-half month pay for every year of service, whichever is higher. The same one-half-month formula applies to certain cases of closure or cessation of operations not due to serious business losses or financial reverses.

    The provision is notably different from Article 302.

    Article 302 expressly defines “one-half month salary” for retirement purposes by adding the 13th month pay and service incentive leave components to 15 days’ salary. Article 298, by contrast, prescribes the amount of separation pay but does not incorporate that statutory definition of “one-half month salary.” This matters because the 22.5-day retirement formula should not simply be imported into Article 298 on the assumption that every reference to “one-half month” carries the same meaning. Verily, the fact that both provisions happen to use the words “one-half month” does not, by itself, make their computations identical.

    Redundancy Is Different Again

    The distinction becomes even clearer in cases of redundancy. Unlike retrenchment, where the Labor Code uses the one-half-month-per-year formula, separation pay for redundancy is based on one month pay or one month pay for every year of service, whichever is higher. The same one-month formula applies to termination due to the installation of labor-saving devices.

    Consider an employee who has rendered ten (10) years of service.

    If the employee’s monthly pay is ₱100,000, the statutory formulas produce materially different results:

    Retirement – 22.5 days × 10 years – ₱750,000, assuming a ₱100,000 monthly salary and a 30-day divisor

    Retrenchment – 1 month or ½ month × years, whichever is higher – ₱500,000 under the ½-month-per-year formula

    Redundancy – 1 month or 1 month × years, whichever is higher – ₱1,000,000 under the 1-month-per-year formula

    The comparison demonstrates why the terminology should not be treated as interchangeable. Retirement uses a statutory 22.5-day definition of one-half month salary. Retrenchment, on the other hand, uses a one-half-month-per-year separation-pay formula, while redundancy uses a one-month-per-year formula.

    What About an “Early Retirement” Program?

    This brings us back to the anecdote.

    The use of the term “Early Retirement Offer” does not, by itself, determine the legal character of the program. The nature of an agreement is determined by its substance and the intention of the parties, rather than by the title or terminology used to describe it. This principle is particularly important where an employer-created program uses the language of retirement but, in substance, provides for voluntary resignation in exchange for a specified separation benefit.

    Thus, the more appropriate inquiry is not simply whether the program was called an “early retirement” offer, but what the parties actually agreed upon. If the terms of the program contemplate the employee’s voluntary resignation in exchange for separation pay, rather than retirement under the applicable retirement scheme, the benefit should be examined according to the terms and legal basis of that arrangement.

    This distinction matters because the 22.5-day definition of “one-half month salary” under Article 302 is specifically prescribed for purposes of statutory retirement pay. It does not follow that the same computation automatically applies to a voluntary separation benefit merely because the employer used the term “retirement” in describing the program.

    At the same time, an employer cannot avoid the statutory requirements governing retirement simply by giving a different name to an arrangement that, in substance, constitutes retirement. The characterization of the program must therefore be determined from the agreement as a whole, including its terms, the circumstances surrounding its implementation, and the intention of the parties.

    In the end, the computation follows the legal character of the benefit. The terminology used by the parties may provide context, but it does not, by itself, determine the parties’ rights and obligations.

    The case described above illustrate a practical point for employers: if a company intends to create a voluntary separation program rather than a statutory retirement program, the distinction should be made clear from the beginning.

    To begin, the program should not be denominated as “Early Retirement Offer”. The program should identify:

    1. Whether the participation is voluntary;
    2. Whether the employee is retiring or resigning;
    3. The legal and contractual basis of the benefit;
    4. The precise computation of separation pay;
    5. Whether the 22.5-day retirement formula applies;
    6. Whether the management retains discretion to approve applications; and
    7. What happens after separation, including any eligibility for future employment.

    Clarity at the implementation stage is considerably preferable to litigating the meaning of the program after the employee has already separated.

    Final Word

    The phrase “one-half month salary” may sound like a straightforward matter of arithmetic. Under Philippine labor law, however, its meaning depends upon the legal context in which it is used.

    For statutory retirement pay, the Supreme Court has settled the interpretation: one-half month salary means 22.5 days, consisting of 15 days’ salary, one-twelfth of the 13th month pay, and the cash equivalent of the prescribed service incentive leave.

    Retrenchment is different. Although Article 298 likewise refers to one-half month pay for every year of service, the provision does not reproduce the statutory retirement definition. Redundancy is different again, providing for one month pay or one month pay for every year of service, whichever is higher.

    For employers, the lesson is straightforward: before implementing a retirement or separation program, determine first what the program legally is, and only then determine how its benefits should be computed.

    For employees, the same principle applies. Before accepting a separation package, it is important to understand not only how much the employer is offering, but also the legal basis upon which that amount has been computed.

    Kristoffer Monico S. Ng is a Philippine lawyer whose practice focuses on labor and employment, corporate and commercial law, tax, energy law, and civil and criminal litigation. He advises businesses and individuals on legal risk, regulatory compliance, taxation, dispute resolution, and complex commercial matters, representing clients before courts, quasi-judicial agencies, and administrative bodies, while also providing strategic legal advice outside the courtroom. He also regularly writes on developments in Philippine jurisprudence and regulation, providing practical insights on legal issues affecting businesses and individuals.

    If you require legal advice concerning the issues discussed in this article, or any other legal matter within these practice areas, you may reach him through e-mail at nico@nlaw.ph to discuss your particular circumstances.